ingruc.com
Copy me on eToroAffiliate link
Personal finance·Published ·Updated ·6 min read

Index funds or individual stocks?

Not stocks vs safety, but *how* you own equities: an index fund, your own picks, or a proven investor. Over 15 years, ~90% of active funds trailed the S&P 500.

The question people ask is "stocks or something safer?" — but that's the wrong axis. Over long horizons owning equities is the safe choice for building wealth, and cash is the risky one, since it will always lose to inflation. The real decision is how you own them.

Index funds or individual stocks?

For most people, most of the time, a broad low-cost index fund is the right default — and the evidence is blunt about why. 90% of actively managed US large-cap funds underperform the S&P 500. These are full-time professionals with research teams, and nine in ten still lost to the simple average over time. That is not an argument against owning stocks; the index is stocks. It's an argument that beating the market is genuinely hard, so the default should be to own it, but cheaply.

Then why does anyone pick individual stocks?

Because the index is an average, and an average can be beaten. But it is real work, and requires a disciplined process. Most who try underperform. Picking stocks well means reading company accounts, understanding where the money comes from, and having the gut to hold through the drops that shake everyone else out.

If you would like to be invested in stocks, but want to avoid the hefty fees that often come with funds, this portfolio might be something for you.

If you're just starting, how to start investing is the place to begin.

Last reviewed 21 August 2026

This is written by someone investing real money in public. See the live portfolio · How copying works

The monthly letter

Stay in the loop.

A letter about once a month: what changed in the portfolio and why, the investment cases behind it, and how I'm thinking about the market. No noise, no weekly filler.

Read by over 4,600 copiers and counting. Your email is used only to send the letter — see the privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.